| |
Gastric Banding |
Sleeve Gastrectomy |
Gastric Bypass |
| |
 |
 |
 |
|
Surgical Procedure
|
- Reversible
- Laparoscopic procedure
- A hollow band of special material is placed at the upper end of the stomach.
- No stomach stapling, cutting or intestinal re-routing required
|
- Not Reversible
- Laparoscopic procedure
- Involves removal of part of the stomach leaving behind a much smaller stomach tube
- Requires stapling
|
- Not Reversible
- Laparoscopic procedure
- A small stomach pouch is created to which a section of the small intestine is attached.
- Requires stomach stapling
|
|
Use of implant
|
A medical device is implanted
|
No use of implant
|
No use of implant
|
|
Advantages
|
- Lowest rate of early complications
- Operation usually takes less than an hour
- Overnight hospital stay
- Low risk of malnutrition
- Minimal vitamin supplementation needed
- Return to work in one to two weeks
- The gastric band is adjustable so it can be customized to individual needs of the patient
- Adjustable for nutrition needs of pregnancy
|
- Decreased stomach volume
- Stomach functions normally allowing most foods to be eaten, just in smaller amounts
- Feel full with less food
- Stomach portion that produces hunger stimulating hormone is removed
- No adjustments required after surgery
- Fewer long term problems
|
- Weight loss continues for 18-24 months post surgery
- Greater weight loss than Band and Sleeve
|
|
Disadvantages
|
- Regular follow up is critical for optimal results
- Band adjustments are required
- Long term problems such as Band Slip, Erosion, Infection, and Pouch Dilatation may occur
|
- Newest weight loss procedure
- 1% chance of leak from staple line
- Longer term results (10-15yrs) uncertain
- Dilation of the sleeve may occur affecting weight loss and leading to weight gain
- Four night hospital stay
|
- Serious risks are involved as it is major surgery
- Malnourishment and anaemia may occur requiring lifelong vitamin and mineral supplementation.
- Dumping syndrome may occur. Nausea, reflux, diarrhoea can occur after ingesting high sugar foods
- Hospital stay of 5 days
- Increased risk of hair loss
|
|
Expected weight loss
|
50-60% excess weight lost over 2 years
|
60-70% excess weight loss over 1 year
|
65 -80% excess weight loss over 18 months
|